Bureaucracy a central concern of trotsky's from the early days of soviet russia was the continued power, and even growth, of bureaucracy under the new communist government. So, while trotsky did form the red army and made contributions when it came to crushing the whites and consolidating socialist power in the new soviet republic, later he became a capitalist roader that could have derailed the revolution. Trotsky's idea that the revolution could not be sustained in conservative europe and had to keep expanding was not as appealing as stalin's 'socialism in one country' michael lynch's book on trotsky is a good place to start. Stalin, trotsky and the struggle for power after lenin's death introduction this activity was designed and used by sally burnham who teaches in peterborough it's an excellent activity for a number of reasons and well-worth reading and thinking about even if you don't teach russian history.
Leon trotsky, also from russia, argued that socialism had to be international, and it was not important to make it happen first in russia he also did not like joseph stalin , who became the leader of the ussr after lenin's death in 1924. Published: mon, 5 dec 2016 the purpose of this paper is to examine how stalin became the sole leader of the soviet union while he was regarded to the politburo as a minor player who had no chance of defeating trotsky. Explain why trotsky failed to become leader of russia by 1928 (12 marks) trotsky failed to become leader of russia by 1928 for two main reasons the first one being his own naivety, shortcomings and weak decisions primarily trotsky's main problem was his ill health throughout his time as a.
Toward a reconsideration of trotsky's legacy and his place in the history of the 20th century 29 june 2001 the following is the text of a lecture given january 21, 2001 by david north, the. Due to plekhanov's opposition, trotsky did not become a full member of the editorial board, but from that point on he participated in its meetings in an advisory capacity, which earned him plekhanov's enmity. As part of your revision, think about the arguments and facts you would use to explain: how stalin came to power in communist russia in 1924 why stalin, and not trotsky, emerged as lenin's successor.
Trotsky did not explain fully how he could call for this while maintaining that russia remained, as before, a degenerated workers' state that had only needed reform what had changed about the structure of this state by 1933 that made revolution, not reform, the only way forward. Why did marji's parents react to her statement about the shah (hint: her family history) because her great grandpa was the emperor until he got kicked out by the shah what was marji's grandfather's job under reza. Stalin, rather than trotsky, succeeded lenin because stalin was the more adept politician and stalin was better at doing the little things that allowed him to gather power to himself trotsky.
Trotsky did not share lenin's belief that it should be peace at any price as foreign commissary, trotsky started the first talks trotsky believed that the russian revolution would be the catalyst for a world revolution with the workers across the world showing their support for the bolsheviks. The statement stalin won because trotsky lacked a power base does not explain the actual reasons as to why trotsky did not succeed lenin as the leader of the soviet state trotsky had the most powerful power base in russia at the time which was that he had control of the red army. Discuss at least three reasons why trotsky did not assume the party leadership 10 explain joseph stalin's career and contribution to the revolution up to and including 1922. Stalin did not succeed in gaining power over lenin lenin remained in power until he suffered a series of three strokes beginning in 1922 which curtailed his activity and ultimately caused his.
The tragedy was not that trotsky was unable to predict in detail the future course of nazism in power, but that there was no political organization capable of putting his ideas into practice but this example illustrates that marxism as a theory is tested by its ability to explain events, not to predict them. Explain trotsky's contribution to the success of the bolsheviks up to 1922  explain why stalin, and not trotsky, emerged as lenin's successor. Why did stalin, and not trotsky, emerge as lenin's successor describe the circumstances of lenin's death and the struggle for power: reasons for stalin's emergence as leader by 1928 lenin, as the leader of the soviet state of the ussr, had died on january the 21st, 1924. Why did stalin become leader after lenin, not trotsky essay sample in the beginning, as lenin end grew nearer, there were five potential leaders, bukharin, kamenev, zinoviev, trotsky and stalin.
Leon trotsky was born lev davidovich bronstein in yanovka, ukraine—in the russian empire—on november 7, 1879 his parents, david and anna bronstein, were prosperous jewish farmers. According to trotsky, the official communist leaders would not follow his policies because they were constituted of not a few cowardly careerists and fakers whose little posts, whose incomes, and more than that, whose hides, are dear to them (trotsky, 'for a workers united front against fascism', december 1931).
The situation was so ripe that trotsky wrote that the german bourgeoisie could only extricate itself from this 'inextricable' position if the communist party did not understand at the right time that the position of the bourgeoisie was 'inextricable' and did not draw the necessary conclusions. Best answer: lenin did not choose a successor although there were many who would have chosen trotsky in light of this, stalin seized power and, to solidify his hold on the soviet union, he had all political opposition eliminated. -trotsky's idea of why stalin gained power is that it was all due to the failure of the international revolution and the isolation, which followed, which showed russia's backwardness and the political apathy of the working class.